Schedule a Retirement Blueprint
— Insights · Standards of Care —

Fee-Only Fiduciary or Commission Advisor

Two questions separate the three arrangements: who pays the professional, and which standard applies given the registration, the service and the circumstances of the recommendation in front of you.

An empty consultation table with a leather chair on one side and a fabric chair on the other, a closed leather folio and a brass desk clock, in a sunlit office
— The Direct Answer —
A fee-only fiduciary wealth manager is paid only by the client and is subject to fiduciary obligations when providing investment advisory services. A commission-based financial professional is paid in connection with the sale of financial products and may be an insurance agent, a registered broker-dealer representative, or both, with different standards applying to insurance and to securities recommendations. A fee-based adviser may be paid both ways. Which standard applies depends on the professional's registration, the service being provided and the circumstances of the recommendation.
— Lindahl Lucas, Founder · Avinci Wealth Management, Inc. —

What to know up front

  • The applicable standard of conduct depends on the professional's registration, the service being provided and the circumstances of the recommendation. One individual can be subject to different standards on two recommendations made in the same meeting.
  • Fee-only removes product commissions. It does not remove every conflict; a fee charged on assets advised carries one of its own.
  • Fee-based is a description of compensation, not a separate registration category, and it does not mean dual-registered. The registration filings tell you more than the label does.
  • Commission-related compensation is generally reflected in a product's own economics rather than billed to you, so the product documents and any surrender schedule are worth reading before signing anything.
  • Avinci Wealth Management is fee-based. The affiliate arrangement is set out below.

The three arrangements

Investment advisory services described on this page are offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser registered in California, Arizona, Illinois, Texas and Nevada. This page is general information for educational purposes and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Compensation arrangements vary by firm; confirm any firm's arrangements in its own disclosure documents.

A fee-only fiduciary wealth manager is paid only by the client, through a percentage of assets advised, an hourly rate, a flat fee or a retainer, and operates as a Registered Investment Adviser. Because the client is the only payer, the adviser's income follows the asset base or the scope of work hired. That creates an incentive of its own: under a fee charged on assets advised, the adviser earns less when portfolio money is used to pay off a mortgage. Fee-only removes product commissions. It does not remove every conflict.

A commission-based financial professional receives compensation associated with the sale of financial products. Depending on the products offered, that professional may be an insurance agent, a registered broker-dealer representative, or both, and different regulatory standards apply to securities and to insurance recommendations. Compensation depends on which product is purchased and how many transactions occur. Under Regulation Best Interest, a broker-dealer must act in the retail customer's best interest when making a covered securities recommendation, without placing its own interests ahead of the customer's. The older suitability standard asked only whether a recommendation fit the customer's needs. Regulation Best Interest generally does not reach an ordinary fixed insurance transaction, which is governed by state insurance law instead.

A fee-based adviser charges client fees and may also receive commissions on certain products, either directly or through an affiliated business. The CFP Board treats this as commission-and-fee compensation. Fee-based does not mean dual-registered: a registered investment adviser can charge advisory fees while a commonly owned insurance agency receives commissions, with no broker-dealer registration involved anywhere in the arrangement. Where an individual is dual-registered, that individual can perform work subject to one standard in the morning and work subject to another in the afternoon. Managing assets is one. Placing a commission product is another.

Which standard applies depends on the registration, the service and the circumstances. That is the one thing worth getting in writing.

How the legal standards differ

Three arrangements, by compensation and standard
DimensionFee-only fiduciaryCommission-basedFee-based
How paidFees paid by the client only: a percentage of assets advised, hourly, flat or retainerCompensation associated with product sales, paid by issuers or other transaction counterpartiesClient-paid advisory fees and potential product-related commissions, earned by the professional or an affiliated business
RegistrationRegistered investment adviser, with the SEC or with a stateInsurance producer, registered broker-dealer representative, or both, depending on the products offeredDepends on the services offered. Dual registration is not required
Governing standardInvestment adviser fiduciary obligations: duties of care and loyaltyRegulation Best Interest on covered securities recommendations; applicable state insurance standards on insurance transactionsInvestment adviser fiduciary obligations for advisory services, applicable insurance standards for insurance transactions, and Regulation Best Interest for covered brokerage recommendations
When it appliesAcross the advisory relationship, generally including agreed ongoing monitoringAt the time of a covered recommendation; any ongoing monitoring obligation depends on the agreed arrangementDepends on the registration, the service being provided and the circumstances of the recommendation
ConflictsAdvisory-fee incentives, including the incentive created by a fee charged on assets advisedIncentives created by product-related compensation; sales contests and quotas tied to specific securities are prohibited for broker-dealersAdvisory-fee incentives plus potential commissions earned by the professional or an affiliated business
Disclosure documentsForm ADV Part 2AProduct documents, applicable insurance disclosures and broker-dealer disclosuresForm ADV Part 2A, applicable insurance disclosures, and brokerage disclosures where relevant

General descriptions drawn from the SEC's final rule on Regulation Best Interest (2019) and SEC staff guidance. Regulation Best Interest applies according to the capacity in which a professional acts. Not a statement about any particular firm other than Avinci Wealth Management.

SEC staff have said the two standards generally yield substantially similar results for a given recommendation, and that Regulation Best Interest cannot be satisfied through disclosure alone. The structural difference is scope: one attaches to a recommendation, the other to a relationship. Registered investment advisers are subject to fiduciary obligations when providing investment advisory services, and whether the federal or a state framework applies depends on where the firm is registered. Avinci Wealth Management is a state-registered investment adviser subject to applicable California fiduciary, disclosure and antifraud requirements. How to evaluate a fiduciary wealth manager explains how that duty attaches service by service.

Where retirement advice stands after the 2026 DOL change

In March 2026, the Department of Labor confirmed the removal of its vacated 2024 Retirement Security Rule, leaving the longstanding five-part test in place for determining fiduciary investment advice under ERISA. Whether a rollover recommendation creates fiduciary status under ERISA depends on the facts and circumstances. Separately, investment advisers remain subject to applicable investment adviser fiduciary obligations, and broker-dealers remain subject to Regulation Best Interest when making covered recommendations to retail customers. Before rolling over a 401(k), confirm in writing which standard applies to that recommendation.

What to compare

Five checks separate one arrangement from another, and none of them is about past performance.

  • How the adviser is paid: a percentage of assets advised, an hourly rate, a flat fee, or commissions.
  • Who funds that pay: you directly, or a product provider through costs built into the product.
  • Which standard applies, and whether it covers the whole relationship or a single recommendation.
  • How conflicts are handled: eliminated, mitigated, or disclosed.
  • How much is coordinated: whether investments, tax, income, insurance and estate work are brought together, or whether the adviser specialises in one and refers the rest.

On conflicts

An SEC staff bulletin states that all broker-dealers, investment advisers and financial professionals have at least some conflicts of interest. A substantive answer names the adviser's conflicts and says how each is eliminated, mitigated or disclosed. "I have no conflicts" is the answer worth probing. The three compensation models and who discloses what shows where each one is reported.

On coordination

Retirement planning often draws on several interconnected areas: investments, tax considerations, retirement income, insurance and estate coordination. Those are the areas our own planning approach covers rather than a regulatory definition of comprehensive financial planning. Firms divide them differently, and there is no single correct division. What matters is knowing where the lines fall before you engage. Ask which areas are handled in-house, which are referred out, and who is responsible for the handoff in each case. What a comprehensive retirement plan includes sets out the baseline.

Where the cost sits

Fee-only advisers receive compensation through advisory or planning fees, which may be invoiced directly or deducted from the client's investment accounts. Fee-based and commission-based arrangements may also involve product expenses, carrier-paid commissions and other compensation that should be clearly disclosed. That is the practical difference, and it is why the two are hard to compare until both are itemised.

Fee-only advisers in the United States typically charge in one of four ways: a percentage of assets advised billed annually, an hourly rate, a flat project fee, or an annual retainer. Percentage fees often decline as the asset base rises, though pricing varies by firm. Hourly and retainer prices follow the scope of the work and whether the engagement is one-time or ongoing. What a fiduciary retirement plan costs in California walks through each model and how to turn a percentage into a number.

A commission-based arrangement can appear to cost nothing because the product company pays. The compensation is reflected in the product's own economics, which vary by product, and it is disclosed in the product documents rather than on a bill. The Government Accountability Office has reported that SEC staff treat broker-dealer variable annuity recommendations as covered by Regulation Best Interest, and FINRA Rule 2330 adds specific requirements for deferred variable annuity transactions. Ask for the product documents and any surrender schedule in writing before signing anything.

Six questions to ask

Six questions and what a substantive answer sounds like
QuestionAnswer to look forAnswer to follow up on
How are you paid for each service you provide?An itemised list by service, in writing"It costs you nothing," or "it depends"
Does anyone other than me pay you in connection with my account?A plain yes or noA hedge, or a change of subject
Do you or an affiliate earn commissions on anything you might recommend?The affiliate and the products are named"Fee-based" offered as though it meant fee-only
When do fiduciary obligations apply, and will you put that in writing?A written statement of which services carry themA verbal assurance with no service-by-service detail
What would my total cost be in the first year?An itemised estimate of expected advisory fees, investment expenses, any insurance or annuity product charges and other applicable costs, with the assumptions and uncertainties explainedA percentage with no itemisation, or a figure quoted with no assumptions behind it
Which planning areas do you coordinate?Investments, tax considerations, retirement income, insurance and estate coordination, with a named person at each handoffA product discussion before anyone has seen your full financial picture

Then verify what you were told. Search the firm on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure system and, for any broker-dealer registration, on FINRA BrokerCheck. Read Form ADV Part 2A: Item 5 covers fees and compensation, Item 10 covers other financial industry affiliations, and Item 14 covers compensation from third parties. Questions to ask a California wealth manager shows where to find each.

Planning in Sherman Oaks

Sherman Oaks sits in the San Fernando Valley within the City of Los Angeles, with the Ventura Boulevard commercial corridor running its length and the Sherman Oaks Galleria at Ventura and Sepulveda.

Households there often arrive with a mix that makes the compensation question concrete: a workplace retirement plan, a brokerage account opened decades ago, an insurance policy bought through a different person entirely, and a trust signed years before any of it. Each piece was sold or advised under whichever standard applied to that transaction at that time, by someone paid in a different way. Sorting out which is which is usually the first useful hour of work, and it comes before any recommendation. Avinci works with households across the San Fernando Valley and the Santa Clarita Valley on investment management, retirement income planning and tax coordination.

How Avinci is paid

Avinci Wealth Management is a Registered Investment Adviser registered in California, Arizona, Illinois, Texas and Nevada, firm CRD #327780, headquartered at 23929 Valencia Blvd, Suite 404 in Santa Clarita, with additional offices in Beverly Hills and Woodland Hills.

Avinci is fee-based, not fee-only. The firm receives advisory fees from clients for investment advisory services. Separately, insurance and annuity products may be offered through our affiliated agency, Lucas Insurance Services, which may receive commissions from issuing insurance companies on the products it places.

Avinci Wealth Management and Lucas Insurance Services are affiliated businesses under common ownership. That creates a financial incentive to recommend products that generate compensation for the affiliated agency. The arrangement is disclosed in our Form ADV and stated in the footer of every page on this site. Read Form ADV Part 2A Items 5, 10 and 14 before any meeting with us, as you would with any firm.

Important disclosures. This material is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized investment, tax or legal advice, or as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or insurance product. This is not tax or legal advice; consult your CPA or attorney before acting on anything described here.

Registration. Investment advisory services are offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser, firm CRD #327780. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Our Form ADV Part 2A brochure describes our services, fees and conflicts of interest, and is available on request and through our IAPD record.

Compensation. Avinci Wealth Management, Inc. is fee-based. Separately, insurance and annuity products may be offered through our affiliate, Lucas Insurance Services, which may receive commissions from issuing insurance companies. This arrangement creates a conflict of interest and is disclosed in our Form ADV. Descriptions of other compensation models and other standards of care on this page are general and are not statements about any particular firm.

Regulatory references. Descriptions of federal and state rules reflect our understanding as of the date of publication and are subject to change. As a California state-registered adviser, Avinci is primarily subject to California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation advertising and antifraud requirements. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

— Common Questions —

Questions about pay and legal duty

Is a fee-only advisor automatically a fiduciary?
Usually, but the two terms measure different things. Fee-only describes how the adviser is paid: by clients only, with no commissions. Fiduciary describes a legal duty. Registered investment advisers are subject to fiduciary obligations when providing investment advisory services, and whether the federal framework under the Investment Advisers Act or a state framework applies depends on where the firm is registered. Confirm registration by searching the firm on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure system rather than relying on the description.
Can a commission-based advisor also act as a fiduciary?
Yes, in one role. An individual registered both as an investment adviser representative and as a broker-dealer representative is subject to fiduciary obligations when providing investment advisory services, and to Regulation Best Interest when making a covered brokerage recommendation. The applicable standard depends on the registration, the service being provided and the circumstances of the recommendation, so a gap can open between the two. Where an insurance or annuity recommendation arises within an investment advisory relationship, applicable advisory fiduciary obligations and the related conflicts must also be considered. Ask which standard applies to each recommendation, and ask for the answer in writing.
How do I verify whether fiduciary obligations apply to my advisor?
Ask directly and get the answer in writing. Then read Form ADV Part 2A: Item 5 covers fees and compensation, Item 10 covers other financial industry affiliations, and Item 14 covers compensation from third parties. Check FINRA BrokerCheck for any broker-dealer history, and look up state insurance licences if an affiliated agency places insurance or annuities. Note that not every adviser files a client relationship summary: the requirement depends on the firm's registration, and state-registered advisers are generally outside the SEC's Form CRS requirement.
What does fee-based mean compared with fee-only?
Fee-only means all compensation comes from the client, with no commissions or third-party payments. Fee-based means client fees plus the possibility of commissions. Fee-based is a description of compensation rather than a separate registration category, which is why the registration filings carry more information than the label does. The CFP Board treats commission-and-fee compensation as distinct from fee-only, and treats a fee-only description by a professional receiving sales-related compensation as a Code of Ethics violation.
How much does a fee-only advisor cost?
It depends which of the four common structures the firm uses: a percentage of assets advised billed annually, an hourly rate, a flat project fee or an annual retainer. A percentage is quoted yearly, which makes it comparable with the ongoing cost of a commission product once both are converted into dollars. Whatever the model, ask for an itemised estimate of the expected first-year cost: advisory fees, investment expenses, any product charges and other applicable costs, with the assumptions and uncertainties explained. For an ongoing relationship the exact figure depends on asset values, transactions and the investments and products selected, so the assumptions matter as much as the number.
Is Regulation Best Interest the same as the fiduciary standard?
No. Regulation Best Interest governs covered broker-dealer recommendations to retail customers. Investment adviser fiduciary obligations govern investment advisory services provided through a registered investment adviser, under the federal or a state framework depending on where the firm is registered. SEC staff have said the two generally yield substantially similar results for a given recommendation, but they differ in scope: one attaches to a recommendation, the other to the advisory relationship. Neither label tells you how the adviser is paid, so compensation still has to be checked separately.
— Thirty Minutes · No Obligation —

Bring your questions to a strategy session

Schedule a Retirement Blueprint Strategy Session and ask the six questions on this page directly. You will leave knowing how we are paid and which standard applies to what.

Schedule a Strategy Session →

Or call us at 888-855-2612

A Strategy Session is an introductory conversation about investment advisory services offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Avinci is fee-based. Any insurance or annuity discussion is conducted separately through our affiliate, Lucas Insurance Services. Tax returns are prepared by your own CPA and estate documents drafted by your own attorney.