Schedule a Retirement Blueprint
— Insights · Choosing an Adviser —

Fee-Only or Fee-Based: How to Choose in California

Both arrangements can deliver comprehensive planning. What separates them is who pays the adviser, which duty attaches to each service, and whether a commissioned product will be part of the plan.

A woman in a navy blazer and a man in a grey jacket reviewing printed statements across a reclaimed-wood table in an office overlooking golden hills
— The Direct Answer —
Choosing between a fee-only and a fee-based adviser in California comes down to four things in order: which legal duty applies to each service, where the firm is registered, how the adviser and any affiliate are paid on each service, and which planning areas the firm coordinates in-house rather than refers out. The compensation label answers the third question only.
— Lindahl Lucas, Founder · Avinci Wealth Management, Inc. —

What to know up front

  • A fee-only adviser is paid by the client and by no one else. A fee-based adviser charges client fees and may also receive commissions, commonly on insurance and annuity products.
  • Both compensation models can create conflicts of interest. Advisers must identify and appropriately address material conflicts, provide required disclosures, and fulfil applicable fiduciary obligations. Certain conflicts may require mitigation or elimination.
  • California investment advisers are subject to fiduciary and disclosure obligations, including requirements to address material conflicts of interest. Where an adviser or an affiliated business may receive insurance or annuity commissions, clients should receive clear information about that arrangement and the incentives it creates.
  • The most useful question is not which label a firm uses. It is the total anticipated cost of the relationship, in writing, separating what you pay directly from what a product provider pays the adviser or an affiliate.
  • Avinci Wealth Management is fee-based. The affiliate arrangement is set out below.

The two compensation models

Investment advisory services described on this page are offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser registered in California, Arizona, Illinois, Texas and Nevada. This page is general information for educational purposes and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Compensation arrangements vary by firm; confirm any firm's arrangements in its own disclosure documents.

An adviser's compensation model answers one question: who pays them. That answer tells you which incentives to watch for, and it is the beginning of the analysis rather than the end of it.

Fee-only means the client is the only payer. According to the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors, a fee-only adviser receives no compensation from any source other than the client, so no product commission is attached to a recommendation. That removes one category of conflict. It does not remove all of them: a fee charged as a percentage of assets advised still creates an incentive against recommendations that reduce those assets, such as paying off a mortgage or purchasing an annuity.

Fee-based means client fees plus the possibility of commissions, most often on insurance, annuity or certain fund products, and often through an affiliated agency rather than the advisory firm itself. The CFP Board's guidance is direct on the underlying point: no compensation method eliminates conflicts of interest.

Neither label describes the standard of care. When providing investment advisory services, a Registered Investment Adviser is subject to fiduciary obligations including duties of care and loyalty, whether it describes itself as fee-only or fee-based. Insurance and annuity transactions are also subject to state insurance laws and standards of conduct, and when an insurance recommendation is made in connection with an investment advisory relationship, additional fiduciary and conflict-of-interest considerations may apply. How advisors are paid sets out all three models and the conflicts inside each.

Fee-only describes how an adviser is paid. Fiduciary describes a legal duty. The two are routinely collapsed into one word, and they are not the same question.

Two compensation models, side by side
FactorFee-onlyFee-based
How the adviser is paidClient fees only: hourly, retainer, a percentage of assets advised, or a flat project feeClient fees, plus commissions on some insurance, annuity or fund products
Main conflict to watchA fee tied to assets advised can create an incentive against advice that reduces those assetsA commission can create an incentive toward a product that pays one, which is why written disclosure matters
Planning services offeredVaries by firm. Comprehensive planning, including insurance analysis and estate-planning coordination, is available under this model. Placing a commissioned product is notVaries by firm. A firm with an insurance affiliate can also place the product itself, with the commission and the conflict disclosed
Fiduciary obligationsApply to investment advisory servicesApply to investment advisory services. Insurance and annuity transactions are also subject to state insurance law, and additional obligations may apply where a recommendation arises within an advisory relationship
Where to read the detailForm ADV Part 2A, Items 5, 10 and 14Form ADV Part 2A, Items 5, 10 and 14, plus any affiliate disclosure

General descriptions of compensation models. Not a statement about any particular firm other than Avinci Wealth Management.

What to compare, in order

Four things, and the order matters more than most people expect.

  • Legal duty. Which services carry fiduciary obligations, and which do not. Ask for the answer service by service rather than as a single claim.
  • Registration. Whether the firm is registered with the SEC or with California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, and whether its Form ADV Part 2A is publicly available.
  • Pay. How the adviser is paid on each service, and whether any commission is disclosed in writing before anything is placed.
  • Scope. Which planning areas are coordinated in-house, which are referred out, and who holds the pen on each handoff.

California's fiduciary standard

The California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation describes a state-registered investment adviser as a fiduciary with an ongoing obligation to act in clients' best interests, citing Hasso v. Hapke (2014). California advisers are also subject to disclosure obligations requiring material conflicts of interest to be addressed. Where an adviser or an affiliated business may receive insurance or annuity commissions, clients should receive clear information about the compensation arrangement and the financial incentives it creates. Fiduciary status in California is something you verify in a filing, not something you infer from a label on a business card.

Where the regulators are looking

The SEC's examination priorities for fiscal year 2025, which govern the firms it examines rather than state-registered advisers, named recommendations to older investors and to people saving for retirement, and covered rollovers from brokerage accounts into advisory accounts. Those are exactly the transactions a pre-retiree is making.

What the 2026 DOL change did and did not do

In March 2026, the Department of Labor confirmed the removal of its vacated 2024 Retirement Security Rule, leaving the longstanding five-part test in place for determining fiduciary investment advice under ERISA. Whether a rollover recommendation creates fiduciary status under ERISA depends on the facts and circumstances. Separately, investment advisers remain subject to applicable investment adviser fiduciary obligations, and broker-dealers remain subject to Regulation Best Interest when making covered recommendations to retail customers. The practical step is unchanged: before you roll a 401(k) anywhere, ask in writing which standard applies to that specific recommendation. Fiduciary or broker in California covers how the frameworks differ.

What to ask before you hire

Six questions, and the answers are more revealing than the answers to anything about performance.

Six questions and what a substantive answer sounds like
QuestionAnswer to look forAnswer to follow up on
Where can I look you up?The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure system for advisory firms and FINRA BrokerCheck for brokers, both showing registration and disciplinary historyNo record found, or a disclosure event the adviser will not walk you through
May I see your Form ADV Part 2A?Provided at no charge, with fees and conflicts set outDelay, or an assertion that the firm does not have one
Which services carry fiduciary obligations?A service-by-service answer, in writingA single blanket claim with no detail on insurance or annuity work
How are you paid on each service?An itemised list by service: advisory fees, investment expenses, product charges, and any commissions received by the adviser or an affiliate"It is all included," or an unspecific answer about commissions
Do you or an affiliate earn commissions?A plain yes or no, naming the affiliate and the disclosed conflictA fee-only description that the firm's own Form ADV Part 2A does not support
Who does the ongoing work?A named person responsible for the account, in writingA handoff to staff you have not met and cannot name

Three free databases verify most of it: FINRA BrokerCheck, the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure system, and the CFP Board's verification tool. Searching all three takes a few minutes. How to evaluate a fiduciary wealth manager covers which services carry the duty and how to read what comes back.

What it costs in California

Advisory fees are most often charged as a percentage of assets advised, billed annually. NerdWallet, citing Envestnet data, reports an industry-wide average of 0.96% a year, which on a $500,000 portfolio works out to roughly $4,800 a year. Flat annual fees and retainers are the other common structure, charged as a set dollar amount rather than as a percentage.

Advisory costs vary with the services provided, the assets managed, account complexity, the compensation arrangement and each firm's own pricing. Published industry averages give context. They are not a quotation for any particular adviser, including us. A fee-based arrangement adds a second component to weigh: compensation a product provider may pay the adviser or an affiliate on an insurance or annuity contract that is placed.

California advisers are subject to fiduciary and disclosure obligations covering material conflicts of interest, compensation arrangements among them. So the more useful request is not the percentage. Ask each adviser to explain the total anticipated cost of the relationship: advisory fees, investment expenses, any insurance or annuity product charges and surrender provisions, and any commissions or other compensation received by the adviser or an affiliated business. Then ask which of those you pay directly and which a product provider pays. What a fiduciary retirement plan costs in California walks through the four common fee models.

Which arrangement fits which situation

Both fee-only and fee-based advisers may provide comprehensive financial planning, including investment management, retirement income strategies, tax coordination, insurance analysis and estate-planning coordination. The appropriate choice depends on the adviser's expertise, the services actually offered, total costs, conflicts of interest and your own needs, rather than on the compensation label alone.

Two practical questions tend to decide it.

Whether a commissioned product will be part of the plan

A fee-only adviser does not place commissioned products. Where an insurance or annuity contract turns out to be appropriate, that adviser analyses the need and the placement happens elsewhere, through a separately licensed agent you engage. A fee-based firm with an insurance affiliate can place it, with the commission and the conflict disclosed in writing beforehand. Neither route is better in the abstract. They differ in who executes, and in which disclosures you should expect to read before anything is signed.

How the engagement is scoped and priced

Hourly and flat-fee engagements suit a defined piece of work, such as a one-time plan or a second opinion. Ongoing relationships suit households whose circumstances keep changing, through a 401(k) rollover, an inheritance, a business sale or the death of a spouse. Both structures exist under both compensation models, so ask about scope and price separately from compensation. California rules shape the substance either way: state tax treatment of retirement income, community property, Proposition 19, and Medicare premium surcharges.

Directories help with the search without substituting for verification. NAPFA, FeeOnlyNetwork and XY Planning Network publish listings of fee-only advisers, and NAPFA membership requires a fee-only compensation structure. Whichever route you take, read the firm's own Form ADV Part 2A rather than relying on a directory listing.

Planning in Thousand Oaks

Thousand Oaks sits in Ventura County, across the county line from the San Fernando Valley, with the Civic Arts Plaza on Thousand Oaks Boulevard anchoring the civic centre and a large share of owner-occupied housing built from the 1960s onward.

That profile shapes the compensation question in a particular way. Where a long-held home represents a large share of net worth, the decisions that matter most are property-related: how the Proposition 13 assessed value carries forward, what Proposition 19 does to a transfer to children, and whether title is consistent with the estate documents. Those are attorney and tax questions that an adviser coordinates with those professionals, and they are unaffected by whether that adviser is fee-only or fee-based. For Thousand Oaks households with significant real estate holdings, it may be useful to ask prospective advisers how they coordinate financial planning with the client's estate-planning attorney and tax professional, in addition to reviewing compensation and conflicts of interest. Avinci works with households across Ventura County and the Santa Clarita Valley on financial planning, investment management and retirement income coordination.

How Avinci is paid

Avinci Wealth Management is a Registered Investment Adviser registered in California, Arizona, Illinois, Texas and Nevada, firm CRD #327780, headquartered at 23929 Valencia Blvd, Suite 404 in Santa Clarita, with additional offices in Beverly Hills and Woodland Hills. Client assets are held with an independent qualified custodian, and clients receive account statements directly from that custodian.

Avinci is fee-based, not fee-only. The firm receives advisory fees from clients for investment advisory services. Separately, insurance and annuity products may be offered through our affiliated agency, Lucas Insurance Services, which may receive commissions from issuing insurance companies on the products it places.

Avinci Wealth Management and Lucas Insurance Services are affiliated businesses under common ownership. That creates a financial incentive to recommend products that generate compensation for the affiliated agency. The arrangement is disclosed in our Form ADV, stated in the footer of every page on this site, and it is why we describe the firm as fee-based rather than using the fee-only label, which would not be accurate.

Under the Retirement Blueprint, insurance is examined alongside investments, retirement income, tax considerations and estate coordination, so a product is considered against the rest of the plan rather than on its own. Those are the five interconnected areas our planning approach covers. They are not a regulatory definition of comprehensive financial planning.

Estate-planning documents and legal determinations are handled by the client's attorney. We assist with gathering financial information, reviewing account records and coordinating administrative steps with the client and the attorney. Decisions concerning legal ownership, trust funding and beneficiary designations remain subject to the attorney's guidance.

Important disclosures. This material is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized investment, tax or legal advice, or as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or insurance product. This is not tax or legal advice; consult your CPA or attorney before acting on anything described here.

Registration. Investment advisory services are offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser, firm CRD #327780. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Our Form ADV Part 2A brochure describes our services, fees and conflicts of interest, and is available on request and through our IAPD record.

Compensation. Avinci Wealth Management, Inc. is fee-based. Separately, insurance and annuity products may be offered through our affiliate, Lucas Insurance Services, which may receive commissions from issuing insurance companies. This arrangement creates a conflict of interest and is disclosed in our Form ADV. Descriptions of other firms' compensation models on this page are general and are not statements about any particular firm.

Third-party data. Fee averages cited on this page are reported by NerdWallet from Envestnet data. They are industry-wide figures offered as context, not a quotation of any firm's fees, including ours, and advisory costs vary by firm, by service and by account. Regulatory descriptions reflect our understanding as of the date of publication and are subject to change. Avinci is a California state-registered investment adviser and is primarily subject to California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation advertising and antifraud requirements. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

— Common Questions —

Questions California retirees ask

Is a fee-based advisor also a fiduciary?
When providing investment advisory services, yes. A Registered Investment Adviser is subject to fiduciary obligations including duties of care and loyalty, whether it describes itself as fee-only or fee-based. Insurance and annuity transactions are also subject to state insurance laws and standards of conduct, and where an insurance recommendation arises within an investment advisory relationship, additional fiduciary and conflict-of-interest considerations may apply depending on the circumstances. Ask for written confirmation of which capacity applies to each recommendation, and read the firm's Form ADV Part 2A for how it is paid.
How do I find a fee-only fiduciary in California?
Start with the NAPFA directory, since NAPFA membership requires a fee-only compensation structure. FeeOnlyNetwork and XY Planning Network also publish directories. Then read the firm's own Form ADV Part 2A rather than relying on the directory listing: Item 5 covers fees and compensation, Item 10 covers other financial industry affiliations, and Item 14 covers compensation from third parties. The CFP Board treats a CFP professional who describes their compensation as fee-only while receiving sales-related compensation as violating its Code of Ethics, and it accepts reports of inaccurate claims.
What does a retirement advisor cost in California?
Most commonly a percentage of assets advised, billed annually, with flat fees and retainers as the other common structures. NerdWallet, citing Envestnet data, reports an industry-wide average of 0.96% a year, which on a $500,000 portfolio is roughly $4,800. That figure is context rather than a quotation for any particular adviser. Costs vary with the services provided, the assets managed, account complexity, the compensation arrangement and each firm's pricing. Ask each adviser for the total anticipated cost of the relationship: advisory fees, investment expenses, any insurance or annuity product charges and surrender provisions, and any commissions received by the adviser or an affiliated business. Then ask which of those you pay directly and which a product provider pays.
Can a fee-based advisor coordinate insurance and estate planning?
Yes, with disclosure, and so can a fee-only adviser. Both models may provide comprehensive planning that includes insurance analysis and estate-planning coordination. What differs is whether the firm can also place a commissioned product itself. Where an adviser or an affiliated business may receive insurance or annuity commissions, clients should receive clear information about the arrangement and the incentives it creates. Estate-planning documents and legal determinations are handled by a licensed attorney. An adviser assists with gathering financial information, reviewing account records and coordinating administrative steps, while decisions concerning legal ownership, trust funding and beneficiary designations remain subject to the attorney's guidance.
Does the 2024 DOL fiduciary rule still affect retirement advice in 2026?
No. In March 2026 the Department of Labor confirmed the removal of its vacated 2024 Retirement Security Rule, leaving the longstanding five-part test in place for determining fiduciary investment advice under ERISA. Whether a rollover recommendation creates fiduciary status under ERISA depends on the facts and circumstances. Separately, investment advisers remain subject to applicable investment adviser fiduciary obligations, and broker-dealers remain subject to Regulation Best Interest when making covered recommendations to retail customers.
Is Avinci Wealth Management fee-only?
No. Avinci is fee-based. The firm receives advisory fees for investment advisory services, and separately, insurance and annuity products may be offered through our affiliated agency, Lucas Insurance Services, which may receive commissions from issuing insurance companies. Avinci Wealth Management and Lucas Insurance Services are affiliated businesses under common ownership, which creates a financial incentive to recommend products that generate compensation for the affiliated agency. The arrangement is disclosed in our Form ADV.
— Thirty Minutes · No Obligation —

Ask us the compensation questions

Schedule a Retirement Blueprint Strategy Session and put the six questions on this page to us directly. You will have our Form ADV Part 2A before any engagement begins.

Schedule a Strategy Session →

Or call us at 888-855-2612

A Strategy Session is an introductory conversation about investment advisory services offered through Avinci Wealth Management, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Avinci is fee-based. Any insurance or annuity discussion is conducted separately through our affiliate, Lucas Insurance Services. Tax returns are prepared by your own CPA and estate documents drafted by your own attorney.